John 9
It’s striking how often the words of scripture sound like words ripped from today’s headlines.  In our scripture reading today, we’ve already been introduced to our topic, but this was to be our topic even before the disaster happened in Haiti.  In our reading from John chapter 9 today, the disciples ask a question that’s very similar to some of the questions people have been asking in these last two weeks concerning the disaster in Haiti.  In newscasts and in conversation all over the globe we hear people asking, “Why?”  We try to find meaning in the midst of human tragedy and suffering, and almost as an automatic human response some wonder, “Who is to blame for such destruction?”

Even this week, we’ve heard a variety of answers: Scientists tell us the disaster is the result of a natural process called plate tectonics which is responsible for the formation of our continents, mountains, valleys, and oceans.  Some say it’s God’s fault.  God must be cruel to create such a world where natural processes are capable of such devastation.  They say a loving God would never allow such suffering.  Others place the blame on the people of Haiti.  They must have done something to deserve punishment from God.  Some point to this kind of tragedy and say: See.  This is proof.  There is no God.

So who do we . . .